Since the EllisLab Discussion Forum addon is not really actively maintained, and basically one needs to buy the Scaffold theme in addition, to make it a bit 2014-ish ($140 total costs), it seems like not the way to future proof a new website.

I was wondering if someone else out there has successfully integrated any other forum software successfully? Vanilla, vBulletin, phpBB, basically anything will do.

But I need my members to discuss things, without adding another layer of registration hassles.

Alternatively: if anyone still has a good experience after-all with the current Discussion Forum module anyway, I'd be happy to hear that too.

Any tips or pointers are very welcome!


I've never fully understood why EllisLabs opted for building a completely separate module for forums when the structure of ExpressionEngine can be used to create fully bespoke forums.

You have a channel called forums, pre-defined categories for sections of the forum - so mimicking EE's own forums, you have a parent category of "ExpressionEngine 2" and 2 child categories "Community Support" and "Development & Programming". Then using frontend entry forms, allow users to post (either as a visitor or ensure they've logged in first). When a user creates a "new topic", they have to select from your custom form submission a relevant category and it creates an entry. Then anyone wanting to reply, it's a comment.

As the official EE forums, you can display the author, the total views, the total replies and the last reply (comment). The search can be built to only target that channel.

You can set it to automatically email the owner of the topic and obviously when someone replies (comments), they can also subscribe to alerts. You can even allow people to subscribe to a thread (entry).

You can use richer third-party wysiwyg editors, instead of the basic EE one, you can add better image upload, with more controls, you can utilise smiley implementation and much, much more.

All the above inclusive of the original EE license without additional cost. I'm not sure how much extra effort would be involved in doing it this way versus native forum module, but considering the difficulty in customising the forum's appearance and the control you'd get from native entries, the EE template route would win me over every time.

And using this add-on, you could even allow for threaded comments - sorry topic "replies".


I don't have any personal expirience with those add-ons, but there are bridges for Vanilla and vBulletin


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.